• Banner 1
  • Banner 2
  • Banner 3

Welcome to Godmothers

Godmothers, a charming Italian eatery nestled in Cape May, NJ, invites diners on a culinary journey steeped in tradition. Known for its warm atmosphere and family-friendly vibe, this gem caters to groups and enthusiasts alike. With a menu that celebrates authentic Italian flavors, each dish is crafted with love and attention, making it a perfect dining spot for both casual outings and special occasions. Highlights include their deftly prepared pasta and inviting outdoor seating, inviting guests to savor delectable meals under the sun. Reservations can be made easily, ensuring a delightful experience where every mouthful tells a story of culinary passion.

Godmothers: Reviews & Ratings

Autumn Canter
Autumn Canter

My husband and I went for dinner. I got the early bird special which includes an appetizer, entree and dessert. Everything was excellent. I felt that it was the perfect portion size. Presentation was beautiful. Waitstaff was wonderful. Its ...

David L.
David L.

Ricotta Gnocchis are Amazing!!!! The food and service were excellent. The wait staff was very helpful and on top of every request. The chef and his wife were very nice and accommodating to kid requests. Yes, although the atmosphere is upscale, you can still bring kids under the age of 8...

Kay Bodnar
Kay Bodnar

Classy but warm atmosphere. Amazing food and killer dessert. It was a little pricey but you do get a good amount of food. I would have to recommend the chicken Alfredo and loaded garlic bread. The grilled chicken for the Alfredo is tender, ...

Donna Bittner
Donna Bittner

With an excellent menu and reasonable prices this is definitely our favorite restaurant that we discovered while on vacation in WEST Cape May! Their Veal Marsalis was the best I have had in years......generous portions to ...

Kathy Whalen
Kathy Whalen

Early bird special is perfect! Great food for a great price. Very classy but casual place. Bring kids, but please keep them, and you, off your devices. Friendly and attentive staff. Perfect for a family celebration or any festive occasion.

Nino Cosoleto-Miller
Nino Cosoleto-Miller

The food was delicious and the service excellent well above par. I have no complaints about Godmothers. The lobster bisque was probably the best Ive ever had, and my shrimp scampi entree was phenomenal as well. Others in my party were ...

Zachary G
Zachary G

The service is excellent and food are both great! We had Will for a server and he was very knowledgeable about the food and very nice to talk to. Not only was the normal menu awesome but the specials were out of this world. 1010 would recommend. Family owned too!

Tom White
Tom White

Food and staff was great went for early bird special great price also

Location

  • Godmothers
    413 S Broadway Cape May, NJ 08204 United States Hotline: (609) 884-4543

Welcome to Godmothers, a delightful gem nestled in the heart of Cape May, New Jersey. This charming Italian eatery, located at 413 S Broadway, invites you to indulge in a culinary experience that brings a taste of Italy to the Jersey Shore. With a reputation built on both quality and warmth, Godmothers stands out as a premier destination for food enthusiasts and families alike.

  • Reservations and Convenience: Godmothers makes dining easy with the option to take reservations, ensuring a table is ready for your group, whether you're celebrating a special occasion or simply enjoying a night out.
  • Diverse Dining Options: The restaurant offers delivery and takeout, accommodating those who prefer to savor their meals at home or on the go.
  • Family-Friendly Atmosphere: With a casual vibe, moderate noise level, and outdoor seating, Godmothers is the perfect spot for families and groups. The establishment welcomes kids and provides a space where everyone can relax and enjoy.
  • Accessibility: The restaurant is equipped for convenience, accepting credit cards, offering bike parking, and providing Wi-Fi for guests.
  • Alcohol and Entertainment: Pair your meal with a selection of alcoholic beverages while catching your favorite game on TV, adding to the vibrant ambiance of Godmothers.

As a food reviewer, my experience at Godmothers was nothing short of delightful. The delightful aromas and welcoming atmosphere immediately set the stage for a memorable meal. The menu showcases a variety of traditional Italian dishes that are prepared with an authentic touch. From perfectly al dente pasta, rich sauces, to fresh ingredients, every bite reminds you of the warm Italian kitchens.

What stood out for me were the house specialties, which beautifully balance tradition and creativity. I was particularly enamored with their homemade pasta dishes, where you can taste the love and skill that goes into each plate. The wood-fired pizzas were also exceptional, boasting a crispy crust and flavorful toppings that could easily compete with those found in Italy.

In addition to the stellar food, the warm and attentive staff made the evening even more enjoyable. They share their passion for Italian cuisine and are eager to recommend dishes tailored to your taste. Overall, my visit to Godmothers was a celebration of flavors, community, and comfort, and I can't wait to return to explore more of what this lovely restaurant has to offer.

Whether you're a resident or just visiting Cape May, Godmothers is sure to leave a lasting impression on your taste buds. Don’t miss out on an Italian experience that's both casual and exquisite. Reserve your table today by calling (609) 884-4543!